1 / 19
Zen Kinetic Art Wind Spinner with magnetic bearing - REMIX for metric hardware and shorter flowers and a LOT of very full instructions! — zdjęcie 1
1 / 19

Zen Kinetic Art Wind Spinner with magnetic bearing - REMIX for metric hardware and shorter flowers and a LOT of very full instructions!

Zamów wydruk tego modelu

Obliczymy ostateczną cenę na podstawie wybranego pliku. Sprawdzisz ją i zaakceptujesz przed płatnością.

Zapisane na tym urządzeniu.

I couldn't find the specified magnets, or the specified main axle screw, or even the specified pivot nail ! So remixed.

Ocena
0 / 5
Polubienia
4
Pobrania
15
Wydruki
0
Wyświetlenia
84
Oceny
0

Aktualizacja u źródła:

Informacje o modelu

Źródło
Printables
Kategoria
Sculptures
Licencja
Creative Commons — Attribution — Noncommercial — Share Alike

Hardware required:

  • 1x Hand-sewing needle 1.5mm diameter or more, and at least 21mm of useable length before the eye starts, or a stainless nail of the same minimum length to under the head.

  • 1x M3 threaded rod at least 85mm long (and a spare if you want to use the mag placement tool)

  • 9x 10x2mm countersunk Neodymium magnets with centre hole 3mm or a little more (3.2mm is ok).

  • 18x 10x2.5mm Neodymium magnets

  • 1x British 1p coin (penny) ideally pre-1992 so it's bronze

  • 1x M3 lock nut, or use an ordinary nut with threadlock glue

  • 3x M3 internal hex-head screws (socket head cap, machine screws) 6mm or 8mm shank

TL;DR   -  Bad luck, if you really want to build this sculpture, you're going to have to read all of it. Or spend weeks repeating all the testing and modification I went through to get mine finished, up to you. Save yourself a lot of time and spiked fingers, hehehe, just READ IT :o)

The first issue I encountered was the magnets. The original specifies 10x2.5mm magnets throughout, countersunk with a 3mm hole. The original article links to a page with 10x3mm magnets and they show as unavailable anyway - and that's the wrong size, 3mm thick will NOT fit in the body tower, they have to be 2.5mm thick to fit that part! 2mm would be too loose. And no, you can't drill holes in magnets. 

I managed to find some 10x2mm countersunk with 3mm hole for the axle here  https://www.first4magnets.com/product/10mm-dia-x-2mm-thick-x-3mm-c-sink-neodymium-magnet-12kg-pull-2446? - they're not cheap and they're only 2mm thick, but they're N42 Neodymium which is powerful and you only need 9 for the axle. I decided to try them and see if 2mm would do, and yes it does the job fine!            

Then I had to find some 10x2.5mm magnets for the main body, so I went for these ones... https://www.first4magnets.com/product/10mm-dia-x-25mm-thick-n42-neodymium-magnets-14kg-pull-19303?  - again they're not particularly cheap but you can get 20 which is enough for the body (only need 18).

If you can't find suitable magnets, you can't really build this model, so start there as that's the hardest bit.

Then for the axle, with no suitable imperial screws available, I decided to use M3 (3mm) threaded rod which I found here https://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B0D4QFVDKC? - you need an absolute minimum of 85mm for the axle, those rods are 130mm so they're great.    

Then for the "nail" which again I couldn't get to original spec, I decided to use a hand-sewing needle (NOT machine-sewing needle). Sewing needles are incredibly hard so the point shouldn't wear down very quickly if at all. I found some in my local sells-everything hardware store but you should be able to find something suitable in haberdashers. You don't even need the specified length of 1 ¼" which would be about 32mm, as I found the optimum length after much experimenting to be 21mm and the ones I found were 1.5mm diameter (quite chunky, any thinner might be a bit too flexible). So just make sure what you're buying will have at least 21mm from the tip to below the eye so you're going to end up with a nice round shank to push into the bottom axle section. If you're really stuck, this set https://www.amazon.co.uk/Qiuyan-Stitching-Upholstery-Crafting-Projects/dp/B0BJKG3MG6  states "diameter about 1.6mm" in the description, but try to buy locally so you can measure for yourself. You can use a nail if you can find a stainless steel one, the diameter isn't critical but you'd need to have a different needle hole in spin-top3 - just ask me if you need a different size hole and I'll supply STL or you can hack the STL in CAD yourself or design a replacement part - it's a very simple part. Take extreme care cutting the needle - you can't saw them, you have to use a strong wire cutter and the ends will suddenly ping off at high speed when it gives way - wear total eye protection and gloves and full skin coverage, hold the bit you want to keep in some pliers, aim the eye-end you don't want into a bin and not anywhere near anyone else. Squeeze very hard on the cutters and pray. I screwed my eyes up as well just to be on the safe side even though I was wearing protectors, hahaha. I take no responsibility for injury, be warned and be careful. Don't make the mistake I did and think you can tidy up the cut end with a metal file - needles are MUCH harder than files and I ruined a good file in a few strokes before realising my error. If you must tidy it up, do it with something like a micromotor running slowly with a tiny cutting disk or a carborundum wheel, again with total eye protection etc, Messing with needles is no joke :o)

Now that you've got M3 rod, nothing on the axle will fit it, HAHAHAHA! So you need my remixed versions of spin-top3 (the needle holder), and spin-top2 for the top of the axle, and the nuts to hold the magnets in place on the axle! As it's threaded rod and not a screw, you'll need an M3 locknut for the top of the axle (or a normal nut and some threadlock glue) and that won't fit inside spin-top1 so I had to remix that as well with a bigger cavity. Don't cut the threaded rod yet, I left mine whole until I'd assembled the whole axle and put all the magnets into the body and done some very careful testing of where the magnets on the axle should actually go. As you'll see later, the instruction to put them "just below the ones in the body" is nowhere near accurate enough to get it working. 

I sketched a 1.5mm hole in my spin-top3 for the needle, and then needed to ream it very slightly with a 1.5mm drill so I could jam the needle in. Put the needle in a vice with the cut end upwards and press spin-top3 down onto it. Then screw the threaded rod into the other end of spin-top3 until it bottoms out in the hole, mark the rod where it meets spin-top3 and unscrew it about 2mm to allow for a little bit of future adjustment if needed.

So now you can add your magnets and printed nuts to build the axle. I recommend finding a way to pre-thread the nuts nice and straight, or you'll find some of them end up cock-eyed. I did this by stacking several nuts in my vice and driving the M3 rod through the whole lot at once, and then leaving them to "set" for an hour or so before unscrewing the rod. While the first and last in the stack might skew a bit, the middle ones should be nice and true, just repeat until you have a set of 6 really good nuts!

Use the photos to set your magnets and nuts to the distances shown from the needle point. Do it as accurately as you can. The magnet positions are surprisingly critical. I did a LOT of tests and worked out that the available "window" for them is a mere 2.2mm. If they're a fraction too low, the axle will just slam into the side of the body. A fraction too high and the axle will be flung out of the top of the body and it's got a needle on it so noooooooo! :o) Not only is that window small, I found that the centre of that window isn't the optimal position. Unloaded, the axle spun for about 1 second in that position. A little higher and I got 2 seconds of spin. A little higher still and I got 3 seconds of spin. A bit above that is the end of the window and it's projectile time! The measurements I've shown are for the optimal position on my spinner - it might not be perfect for yours, but at least it should be very near indeed and only need slight tweaking if it's tending to want to go to the sides (needs the axle tweaked higher) or trying to lift out (needs the axle tweaked lower). I've included measurements between the groups but those are just a double-check really, the critical ones are from needle tip to top of each group. Another reference point is that I found the optimal position is for the top nut of each group to be about 0.5mm (roughly one full turn of the nut) below the point at which the axle tries to leap out at you, so you can set the bottom group like that without the other magnets in place, then add the others using the photos as a spacing guide.

Now a note about the main body. This was designed for an American penny which is not the same size as a British penny! Ours is slightly bigger so it won't fit in the recess. I remixed this to accommodate the British penny. Ideally find a pre-1992 penny because they were made of bronze then, if you use a 1992+ penny then it will be made of copper-plated steel and could rust once you've punched through the thin copper coating. I used a centre punch to put a tiny locating dent exactly in the middle of my penny so I could be sure to sit the needle dead centre when assembling. I also used a little very thin double-sided sticky tape to hold the penny in place so it wouldn't pop out when assembling. Also, and extremely critically, you need to examine your slicer very carefully before printing the body. My Cura wanted to do roofs over the magnet cavities by painting infill lines in mid air. Nope, that's not going to work. I did a test section and the roof can droop leaving fiddly bits inside the magnet slots and they are impossible to clean up in post processing - those cavities have to be PERFECT, every single one of them. You can specify ALL WALLS (at least 15 would do it) and that would be fine but my Elegoo N3P wanted to take over 7 hours to print that, so I forced it to do 15 walls just in the regions towards the tops of the magnet cavities by using 3 block tools and got it down to about 4 hours. I also used a 2-line brim with 0.7mm spacing so it wouldn't stick to the model - I do that to force Cura to print the first layer in a sensible order instead of fiddly bits first which might detach. 

So now you should have an axle with a needle and holder, three sets of three magnets, each set having a pair of printed nuts holding them in the correctly measured positions. Don't add spin-top2 and spin-top1 yet, just have the bare threaded rod at the top. Now you need to put the magnets into the main body. This would be quite easy with countersunk magnets as they could be passed as a stack into the model on a rod and each one pressed into place by sliding it off the stack into the hole. If your fingers are small enough and strong enough, you may still be able to apply them from a stack. I couldn't, so I designed a placement tool which I've included in the STLs. It uses another M3 rod to grip a magnet while placing it, and I also included a simple little knob to print in TPU to put on the end of the rod so it doesn't dig into the finger or thumb that's pressing on the rod to hold the magnet in the delivery slot! Doing this will drive you nuts because every magnet must be in the same orientation as all of the others, as well as the same as the ones on the axle, or it won't work!!! If you fumble with a magnet, check its orientation again before inserting. Once a magnet is in the body, it's not coming out again without a major fight. Use the rounded contour of the insertion tool to really shove home each magnet once it's in its slot. Also be extremely careful with Neodymium magnets, they're 10x stronger than ferrite magnets and if you get some skin pinched between them when they lunge together then it's really going to hurt and could cause some tissue damage. Magnet attraction speed is faster than human reflex, so if you're not in full control and ahead of the game when you bring magnets near each other then they'll slam together and nip you or smash themselves to pieces.

Finally you should have a body and an axle which you can try putting together. That's hilarious, mind those fingers on the needle, don't let go in case it flies out at you, it'll try to crash into the sides all the time as you try to put it in, but you'll eventually get it home with the needle sitting on the coin and ideally in the tiny dent you put in the coin :o)  Now, does it spin ok? If so, you're on your way to a working model. It has no significant weight yet so it may not spin for long. My assembly ended up with spin-top2 just touching the top printed nut on the axle, and that happened to give nice clearance for the M3 allen-key-head screws I used to attach spin-top1. Take the axle out of the body, add spin-top2 by gripping an unpopulated part of the axle with pliers so you don't disturb the magnets, try to get it nice and straight on the threads, take it down to the top nut and then add a lock nut on the top or a nut with some threadlock etc. Now you can cut off the excess rod and add your spin-top1. Fumble the axle back into the body again, hehehe, and give it a spin. You should be able to get it to go for about 3 seconds if you spin it neatly and don't make it wobble too much. 

If all is well, now you can start printing the leaves and flowers. I did the whole floral arrangement in clear Giantarm PLA which is a pain to print with but is very transparent, and then added hand-painted acrylics to colour all the bits. Choose the shorter "flower" for the one I made, or the original one for the original model's longer flowers. As long as you print exactly the same part for each of the sets of 4 holes in the top of the spinner, you'll have a balanced sculpture which should just spin and spin with the slightest breeze. 

The final issue I had was with the vase. The original is too loose a fit on the main body and it wobbles around. I shimmed mine temporarily with masking tape but the vase really needs to be scaled smaller by a % in the X-Y axes. Trouble is it takes hours to print one, so if anyone happens on the perfect scaling to fit the body snugly please let me know! I'll probably have to slice off the top section and a piece of the bottom stability ring and do test prints on those with scale factors to check against the body before risking another attempt on the whole vase. *******UPDATE - SOLVED! Can't really scale the vase as the bits that fit the mag body aren't quite identical. So I made two collars - one to fit sideways through the vase neck and then upright it and slide it into the base cylinder - it's tight so remove any elephant foot from the collar before putting it in. The other collar fits over the top of the mag body, there should be space there still even with the heads of the top section retaining screws. You may still need to use a deburrer to remove a little from the inner edge of the vase neck, I couldn't make the collar any thinner, then the whole assembly will be very snug indeed with no wobble at all between mag assembly and vase. Sorted!

Please Like this model if you find it useful.

If you REALLY like it, https://www.buymeacoffee.com/gigabeast :o)