Nasty Unknot Puzzle
We calculate the final price from your selected file. You review and accept it before payment.
Saved on this device.
Remove the string from the nasty unknot.
- Rating
- 0 / 5
- Likes
- 1
- Downloads
- 2
- Makes
- 0
- Views
- 13
- Reviews
- 0
Updated at source:
Model information
- Source
- Printables
- Category
- Puzzles & Brain-teasers
- License
- Creative Commons — Attribution — Noncommercial — Share Alike
The unknot, in its simplest form, is just a circular loop with no crossings. It is the most trivial knot - it is so trivial that it is referred to as the unknot. However, I feel that name is a little unfair - the unknot can be twisted and tangled up to make it really hard to tell if it is the unknot or some other non-trivial knot. In The Knot Book, Colin Adams shows something he calls "a nasty unknot" with 7 crossings (pg 16). If you use just Reidemeister moves, you must actually increase the number of crossings before you are able to simplify it to a loop. Does that look like the unknot to you?

I thought this might make a good puzzle - tie a loop of string around it and try to remove it. Karl Scherer made some beautiful Puzzle Pendants that utilized this idea - twist the unknot into something visually interesting and try to remove a ribbon from it.
I've been able to solve it a couple of times, so I know it's possible, but I haven't yet been able to figure out a consistent way to remove the string. Update: I was able to figure out a way to reliably remove the string. Not sure if it is the most efficient, but it works!
Printing
I printed with supports on. There were a few places where the slicer thought it needed support so I just went with it.
Starting Configuration
The printed frame contains a sideways figure-8 in the center. Pass the string down through one hole, then back up through the other hole. Tie the ends of the string, and you are ready to go!

You'll need a string of length around 18 inches. The nylon string I used in the pictures can be found here. These can be cut to size and have a break-away clasp which comes in handy if you get all tangled up or want to reset the puzzle without going through the steps. Take a look at some of my other disentanglement puzzles that can give you some more use out of the spool of string.
Analysis
I've tried - but haven't gotten very far - to make a computer program that can solve these types of problems where there is a string wrapped around some complicated looking projection of the unknot. The Unknotting Problem, where the goal is to determine if a knot diagram is a representation of the unknot, has no known polynomial-time solution, so it's doubtful there is an efficient algorithm in general to solve these types of puzzles. If the frame were made out of string too, it would be really easy to separate the two parts. So why is it so difficult when one of them is rigid?