Brachistochrone – Cycloid Race for the Classroom
We calculate the final price from your selected file. You review and accept it before payment.
Saved on this device.
Three steel balls race down a straight line, a cycloid and a deep curve. Which one wins? Find out in slow motion!
- Rating
- 0 / 5
- Likes
- 1
- Downloads
- 1
- Makes
- 0
- Views
- 18
- Reviews
- 0
Updated at source:
Model information
- Source
- Printables
- Category
- Physics & Astronomy
- License
- Creative Commons — Attribution — Noncommercial — Share Alike
Which path from A to B is the fastest – the straight line, the cycloid or the deep curve? Three steel balls start at the same moment, one comb pull releases them all. The race is over in a blink, so film it in slow motion with a phone or tablet and let the video decide.
Made for physics lessons: track labels and lid title come in 7 languages, and everything – comb, balls and finish module – stows inside the body.
How to use
Take the comb and the three balls out of the storage bay, slide the finish module into the joint at the end of the tracks.
Insert the comb, put one ball on each track at the start.
Start the slow-motion recording, hold the device with one hand and pull the comb briskly with the other – the device tips over if you don't hold it. Perfect for groups of 2 to 4 students: one holds, one pulls, one films.
The joint between the orange body and the black finish module is the finish line. Play the video back and see who crosses it first.
Push the comb back in for the next run. It is captive on purpose, so it can't get lost in class. To take it out for storage, pull it to the stop, push a straightened paper clip into the small hole next to the comb and pull the comb out the rest of the way.
Balls: steel balls, 15 mm. My printed Threaded Ball and Hex Nut Ball in 15 mm work too – once in a while one flies over the end wall.
Languages: English (EN), German (DE), Spanish (ES), French (FR), Italian (IT), Dutch (NL) and Portuguese (PT). The last five aren't checked by native speakers – if a term is wrong, please tell me in the comments.
Not a toy for small children – small parts, choking hazard.
Print Instructions
The PrusaSlicer projects (Prusa MINI+, one per language) include all settings, one bed per part (body, comb, finish module and the three lids). The start coupon has its own project.
Material: PETG. PLA at your own risk – the springy parts (comb hook, finish module and lid snaps) don't hold well in PLA, and the large body may come loose from the bed during the long print. If you try PLA, please share your results.
Body (≈ 266 g, ≈ 14 h on the Prusa MINI+)
Profile: Prusa MINI+ "0.20mm STRUCTURAL @MINIIS 0.4" – not SPEED, it makes the comb channel too narrow. Bambu Lab A1 mini: standard 0.20 mm profile.
Infill: gyroid 15 % (required, keeps the bottom flat) · 3 perimeters.
Temperature at the lower end of your PETG (about 240 °C) – find it with my Temp Tower Compact. Bed 80–85 °C for the whole print – don't lower it after the first layer.
Clean the bed with dish soap and water. Print without drafts; an enclosure helps.
Elephant foot compensation on.
No skirt, no brim, no supports. On printers with a larger bed you can add mouse ears at the three corners – keep the bear paws anyway.
After printing, remove the bear paws at the three corners: lift the paw, snap off the claw, deburr if needed.
The corners may still lift a little, especially without an enclosure – that's what the lids are for (see below).
Lids – three versions, title by color change after the second layer (already set in the projects):
Cover (recommended): fits even if the corners lifted a little, and covers the gap.
Short: 2 mm shorter, also fits a slightly lifted body.
Standard: full length, fits only a body that lies flat.
Not sure? Put the printed body on a flat surface: if the lower left corner (lid side) lifts, take Cover or Short.
Lids are stiff at first and get smoother after sliding them back and forth a few times.
Comb, finish module, lids: same PETG and temperature as the body – hotter, matte PETG foams up and the lids get too tight.
Colors: print the body in a bright color like orange – steel balls stand out against it in the video. A dark finish module makes the finish line easy to see.
Start coupon (optional test print, ≈ 35 g, ≈ 2 h): the start section of the body with the regular comb, same profile as the body. Checks comb, hook, simultaneous start and fits on your printer before you commit to the long body print. It doesn't show warping – that only affects the large body.
Troubleshooting
Small pimples on the top surface → print the top layer slower.
The finish module catches at the joint → check the groove for ridges and deburr lightly.
Design Highlights
One comb, one moment. All teeth touch their ball at the same point, so all three balls start at the same time and from the same height.
The joint is the finish line. Orange body against the black finish module – easy to read in slow motion.
Everything stows inside. Comb, balls and finish module have their own place in the body, the lid snaps shut – and two units stack into one compact block.
Three lids for real-world prints. Long flat prints like this body can lift at the corners, especially without an enclosure. Instead of asking for fiddly settings, there are three lids: Standard for a flat body, Short and Cover still fit when the corners lifted a little.
Used in real lessons. 8 units are in use in my wife's physics lessons at school – tested at home by my kids and me.
Pictures 7 to 10 show the prototypes and coupons behind this model.
Model Origin
Original design by HogiBear.
License
CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
The HogiBear name and the HB logo are not part of this license.
HogiBear – designed in FreeCAD, every file checked for printability.
Questions, ideas or photos of your print? Leave a comment – English or German, both welcome.
Viel Spaß beim Drucken!